The problem is you are running 120v so there are not many VFD Drives that would be better than what you have, 1.5Kw is normally the limit for 120v single Phase supply, the other spindle should of run though, but not that great, so I think it was damaged
So, you should change the Parameters back to the original set I posted except for your motor spec's need to be changed Amps 7 for the 1.5Kw
Bigger is not always better, if you don't have the juice to drive it, 240v the 2.2Kw works best