Hi Roger.
Yes, it Could be the parallel cable, or even parallel port. Open the Y DB9 shell and look for tiny wire bridging contacts. If that all checks out you can open the G 540 case, (small screwdriver, gently pry up each corner of cover) and swap Y drive with A drive. If it doesn't work then, it's not the drive. If it DOES work then, you can ship the offending drive back to Gecko for replacement. (call first) IIRC, The G540 will run with only 3 drives, but better call and make sure.
CR.
http://crevicereamer.com
Too many PMs. Email me to my name plus At A O L dot com.